One of Buffalo's most unique pizza restaurants

Famous for our fried green tomatoes, My Tomato Pie provides casual Italian fare including great pizza, local craft beers, catering and a warm inviting bar.

View Menu
Section main imageSection feature image
Section main imageSection feature image

Locally owned and operated

We are one of Buffalo's most unique casual dinning restaurants. Our menu includes homemade soups, gourmet pizzas, calzones, pastas, and delicious sandwiches served on homemade foccacia bread. We also serve Gluten-Free items, including pasta and pizza, and homemade deserts like Key lime and peanut butter pies. Private dining is also available in our banquet rooms, seating up to 55 guests. Our full bar is perfect for any event or just a nice meal with friends and family.

View Menu

Casual Italian fare

 •

Beer on tap

 •

Kid friendly menu

 •

Banquet room

 •

Catering

Casual Italian fare, Beer on tap, Kid friendly menu, Banquet room, Catering

What people are saying...

  • I would have to say I was more than pleased and shocked by this place. Cooked exactly to my liking with the great smell and taste I'm really happy. They had my pizza done and waiting for pickup in 15min!! That was amazing!! Next time I will go eat inside due to not expecting how nice and big it is in there. Nice size bar, huge dining and separate banquet area as well. Give it a try!!

    J.S

  • What a fun place to eat dinner! The inside of the restaurant feels so classy for a pizza place. The menu options are great.

    Grace S.

  • I love my tomato pie I've been going for well over a decade. I first went there when they were still on Sherdian and was happy to see them stay around after whole foods took over. I love their minestrone soup and their pizzas. I hope to be able to go here for many more decades.

    Joe Z

1 / 2