Skip to Main content
Gift Cards
  • My Tomato Pie

    My Tomato Pie

My Tomato Pie Amherst

3055 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Amherst, NY
Menu
My Tomato Pies (Pizza)
Take-Out Beverages
Catering - Drop Off
Catering - My Burger Bar
Catering - It's My Birthday
Please Select for Curb Side Pick Up:

Featured Items

  • Large 16" Pizza

    Start with our signature homemade pizza dough and choose your base: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Customize your creation with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), then we finish it off with the finest Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $25.00
  • French Fries (Small)

    Premium skin on cooked to order with tomato basil dipping sauce (nut).

    $6.00
  • Personal 7" Pizza

    Start with our signature homemade pizza dough and choose your base: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Customize your creation with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), then we finish it off with the finest Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $8.00

Menu

Today's Specials

Daily Specials
  • Smothered Lemon Pepper Chicken

    Tender grilled chicken breast seasoned with zesty lemon pepper, smothered in a savory blend of cream cheese, marinated artichokes, roasted red peppers, crispy breadcrumbs, and melted mozzarella. Served over a fragrant bed of lemon tarragon rice and fresh asparagus, then finished with a rich roasted garlic and herb butter. Bursting with flavor in every bite.

    $27.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Starters

  • Bavarian Pretzel Sticks

    Three warm, soft Bavarian pretzel sticks, perfectly baked and topped with coarse salt. Served with your choice of two rich and flavorful dipping sauces: Craft Beer Cheese, Jalapeño Pepper Cheese, or Creamy Honey Mustard. A perfect shareable appetizer or snack!

    $12.00
  • Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls

    Two hand-rolled egg rolls stuffed with spicy Buffalo chicken, melted cheese, and crisp celery, fried to golden perfection. Served with chunky blue cheese dressing for the perfect balance of heat and cool. A bold twist on a Buffalo classic!

    $14.00
  • Coconut Shrimp

    Five crispy, golden-brown shrimp rolled in shredded coconut and lightly fried to perfection. Served with a sweet chili dipping sauce for the perfect balance of crunch and flavor. A tropical twist on a classic favorite!

    $16.00
  • Hummus + Pita Plate

    Garlic hummus served with a toasted white or wheat pita.

    $12.00
  • Mama Rose's Stuffed Hot Peppers

    Mama Rose's famous stuffed banana peppers filled with fresh ground sausage, Romano, Cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese. Served with two garlic bread sticks.

    $17.00
  • Mediterranean Platter

    Hummus, Kalamata olives, roasted red peppers, feta, tomatoes, red onions, and served with a toasted white or wheat pita.

    $17.00
  • Nachos

    Nacho chips topped with a blend of Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, Jalapenos, fresh tomatoes, black olives, salsa, and sour cream side.

    $16.00
  • Pizza Bread

    Our homemade dough topped with olive oil, fresh herbs, and Romano cheese. Served with our basil pesto (nut) and tomato sauce for dipping.

    $13.00
  • Spinach Bread

    Fresh spinach, tomatoes, provolone, and romano cheese baked on a seasoned 12" Italian roll.

    $12.00

Soups

At My Tomato Pie, we believe that nothing beats the comfort of a hot bowl of homemade soup, especially during the chilly Buffalo months! That’s why we make our soups fresh every single day, right in our kitchen. You can always count on our two signature soups: Our Specialty Tomato Basil Soup – Rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor, it's a customer favorite! Minestrone Soup – A hearty classic, packed with fresh vegetables and savory broth. When the Buffalo weather gets colder, we like to add a third rotating soup to the mix! This extra option changes frequently—sometimes even throughout the day—so you’ll always find something new and delicious to warm you up.
  • Tomato Basil Soup Bowl

    A rich and creamy blend of ripened tomatoes and fresh basil, finished with a touch of Asiago cheese. Topped with our house-made croutons for the perfect bite. A customer favorite!

    $7.00
  • Tomato Basil Soup Large

    A rich and creamy blend of ripened tomatoes and fresh basil, finished with a touch of Asiago cheese. Topped with our house-made croutons for the perfect bite. A customer favorite!

    $12.00
  • Vegetable Minestrone Soup Bowl

    A hearty, classic Italian soup with seasonal vegetables and tender ditalini pasta, simmered in a rich, flavorful vegetable broth. A warm and comforting favorite, perfect for any time of year!

    $7.00
  • Vegetable Minestrone Soup Large

    A hearty, classic Italian soup brimming with seasonal vegetables and tender ditalini pasta, simmered in a rich, flavorful vegetable broth. A warm and comforting favorite, perfect for any time of year!

    $12.00

Salads

  • House Salad (Small)

    Mixed greens, ripe tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, garbanzo beans, and carrots tossed with your choice of dressing.

    $9.00
  • House Salad (Large)

    Mixed greens, ripe tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, garbanzo beans, and carrots tossed with your choice of dressing.

    $13.00
  • Caesar Salad (Small)

    Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, crunchy homemade croutons, and freshly grated cheese.

    $10.00
  • Caesar Salad (Large)

    Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, crunchy homemade croutons, and freshly grated cheese.

    $14.00
  • Cobb Salad

    Smoked turkey breast, sliced ham, egg, tomato, bacon, and crumbled bleu cheese over mixed greens with your choice of dressing.

    $20.00
  • Pizza Salad

    Our House Creamy Tomato Basil (contains nut) Salad served with a baked pizza crust seasoned with olive oil, garlic, fresh herbs, and cheese.

    $18.00
  • Mediterranean Salad

    Mixed greens with tomatoes, red onions, kalamata olives, and feta cheese in a lemon vinaigrette.

    $17.00
  • Strawberries and Goat Cheese Salad

    Mixed greens with strawberries, goat cheese, candied walnuts, and red onions tossed in balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Seasonal April-October

    $18.00
  • Antoinette's Chopped Salad

    Mixed greens, Italian salami, prosciutto, egg,olives,onions, tomatoes, artichoke hearts,roasted red peppers, chickpeas, and Romano cheese tossed in balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

    $20.00
  • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Stuffed Tomato Salad

    A ripe tomato stuffed with cranberry walnut chicken salad, surrounded by a bed of mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette.

    $18.00
  • Albacore Tuna Stuffed Tomato Salad

    A ripe tomato stuffed with white Albacore tuna salad, surrounded by a bed of mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette

    $18.00

Pita Sandwiches

Our signature stuffed pita sandwiches are built with locally made Father Sam’s Pita, baked fresh right here in Buffalo. Each one is generously filled with bold flavors and fresh ingredients, making them a satisfying choice for lunch or dinner. Every sandwich comes with your choice of side: Pasta Salad, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Homemade Chips, French Fries, or a crisp apple. Taste the local difference in every bite!
  • Lemon Chicken Pita Sandwich

    Tender marinated grilled chicken breast tucked into your choice of toasted white or wheat Father Sam’s pita, made locally in Buffalo. Stuffed with mixed greens, diced tomatoes, red onion, and crumbled feta, then drizzled with our zesty lemon vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side: Pasta Salad, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Homemade Chips, French Fries, or a crisp apple.

    $19.00
  • Caesar Pita Sandwich

    Grilled chicken breast, crisp Romaine lettuce, and freshly grated Romano cheese tossed in our signature homemade Caesar dressing. All stuffed into a warm toasted, locally made Father Sam’s white or wheat pita. Served with your choice of side: Pasta Salad, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Homemade Chips, French Fries, or a crisp apple.

    $19.00
  • Veggie Pita Sandwich

    A garden-fresh blend of garlic hummus, mixed greens, crisp romaine, shredded carrots, diced tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, and crumbled feta cheese, all tossed in our zesty lemon vinaigrette. Stuffed in your choice of toasted white or wheat Father Sam’s pita, proudly made in Buffalo. Served with your choice of side: Pasta Salad, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Homemade Chips, French Fries, or a crisp apple.

    $19.00
  • Steak Pita Sandwich

    Tender 8oz grilled sirloin, sliced and stuffed into a warm, locally made Father Sam pita—your choice of toasted white or wheat. Layered with fresh mixed greens, diced tomatoes, feta cheese, and red onion, then finished with a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side: Pasta Salad, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Fresh Homemade Chips, French Fries, or a crisp apple.

    $24.00

Wraps

Includes side of pasta salad, chips, or apple
  • Albacore Tuna Diablo Wrap

    Albacore Tuna mixed with a combination of hot banana peppers and jalapeno peppers with lettuce, and tomatoes in a white or wheat wrap.

    $18.00
  • Turkey Club Wrap

    Oven roasted turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, diced bacon, and cheddar/jack cheese in a white or wheat wrap with garlic mayonnaise.

    $18.00
  • Portobello Wrap

    Roasted Portobello mushrooms, spinach, roasted red peppers, and goat cheese tossed in balsamic vinaigrette in a white or wheat wrap

    $18.00
  • Steak Wrap

    Thinly sliced rib eye steak with marinated mushrooms, red onion, mozzarella and provolone cheese with hot mayo in a white or wheat wrap.

    $19.00

Focaccia Sandwiches

Includes side of pasta salad, chips, or apple
  • Albacore Tuna Melt Focaccia

    Albacore Tuna with lettuce and tomato topped with melted Monterey jack and cheddar cheese on homemade focaccia bread.

    $18.00
  • Blackened Chicken Focaccia

    Cajun seasoned chicken breast with melted Monterey jack and cheddar cheeses, sliced red onion, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing on homemade focaccia bread.

    $19.00
  • Chicken Florentine Focaccia

    Grilled chicken breast with sautéed spinach, melted Fontina cheese, and garlic mayonnaise on homemade focaccia bread.

    $19.00
  • Chicken Focaccia

    Lightly breaded chichen cutlet with sundried tomato spread, melted mozzarella and asiago cheese on homemade focaccia bread.

    $19.00
  • Ham Focaccia

    Thinly sliced Sahlen's ham, melted provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, and tomato on homemade focaccia bread with pesto mayo.

    $18.00
  • Steak Portobello Focaccia

    8oz Grilled sirloin, roasted portobello mushrooms, spinach, topped with melted gorgonzola cheese on homemade focaccia bread.

    $26.00
  • Turkey Focaccia

    Oven roasted turkey breast, lettuce,tomato, melted monterey jack and cheddar cheese on homemade focaccia bread with cranberry mayonnaise. Add bacon $I extra.

    $18.00

Sandwiches

Includes side of pasta salad, fries, homemade chips, or apple.
  • Portobello Melt Sandwich

    Roasted portobello mushrooms, mixed greens tossed in balsamic vinaigrette, and garlic mayonnaise with melted fontina cheese served on an Italian roll.

    $18.00
  • Meatball Sandwich

    Meatballs, melted mozzarella cheese and Mama Rose's homemade tomato sauce.

    $18.00
  • Steak Sandwich

    8oz Grilled sirloin, caramelized onions with melted mozzarella cheese on an Italian roll.

    $24.00
  • Steak Hoagie

    Thinly sliced rib eye steak with marinated mushrooms, sweet peppers, caramelized onions, mozzarella and provolone cheese.

    $18.00
  • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich

    All white meat, cranberries, walnuts, celery, mayonnaise, and lettuce on a croissant.

    $18.00

Burgers - My Burger Bar

At My Tomato Pie, we're serving up My Burger Bar’s legendary custom burger blend—crafted from whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts for a flavor that’s truly unmatched. We take pride in crafting the perfect burger from the ground up—literally. Our custom blend starts with whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts, expertly combined to deliver unmatched flavor, rich juiciness, and a perfectly balanced bite. Every bite is packed with bold, beefy goodness, making these burgers an instant favorite. All burgers come with your choice of one delicious side: pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple. 🔥 Experience the burger that keeps you coming back for more! 🔥
  • Classic Burger

    Crafted from a premium blend of whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts, our 1/2 Pound Beef Burger is rich, juicy, and full of flavor. Topped with melted American cheese, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and fresh red onion, all complemented by our signature creamy tomato basil sauce. Served on a toasted brioche bun for the perfect bite. Choose your side: pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple.

    $20.00
  • Bleu Burger

    A half-pound of our signature beef blend—crafted from whole sirloin and brisket primal cuts—grilled to juicy perfection. Topped with creamy bleu cheese, crispy smoked bacon, fresh lettuce, ripe tomato, and red onion, all nestled in a buttery brioche bun. Served with your choice of one side: pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple.

    $21.00
  • Smokehouse Burger

    This hearty ½-pound burger is made from a premium blend of whole sirloin and brisket, grilled to juicy perfection. Topped with crispy smoked bacon, golden onion rings, fresh lettuce, ripe tomato, tangy BBQ sauce, and a melty blend of Cheddar and Jack cheese, all served on a toasted brioche bun. Comes with your choice of one side: pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple.

    $21.00
  • Spinach Burger

    Our half pound Beef Burger is made from a premium blend of whole sirloin and brisket, grilled to perfection, and topped with sautéed spinach, savory mushrooms, and creamy melted Fontina cheese. Served on a toasted Brioche bun, this burger delivers unbeatable flavor and quality. Served with your choice of pasta salad, macaroni salad, potato salad, crispy fries, coleslaw, or a fresh apple.

    $21.00

Fries & Rings

  • Cajun Tossed Fries (Basket)

    Golden, crispy premium skin-on fries, fried to order for the perfect crunch. Hand-tossed in a bold, savory Cajun dry rub and baked to lock in the rich, zesty flavors. A perfect balance of heat and spice in every bite!

    $13.00
  • Cajun Tossed Fries (Side)

    Golden, crispy premium skin-on fries, fried to order for the perfect crunch. Hand-tossed in a bold, savory Cajun dry rub and baked to lock in the rich, zesty flavors. A perfect balance of heat and spice in every bite!

    $8.00
  • French Fries (Basket)

    Premium skin on cooked to order with tomato basil dipping sauce (nut).

    $11.00
  • French Fries (Small)

    Premium skin on cooked to order with tomato basil dipping sauce (nut).

    $6.00
  • Loaded Fries (Basket)

    One pound of fries topped with a blend of Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, bacon, and chives with ranch side.

    $15.00
  • Onion Rings (Basket)

    Onion rings beer battered and fried to a golden crisp. Served with our tomato basil dipping sauce (nut).

    $12.00
  • Onion Rings (Side)

    Onion rings beer battered and fried to a golden crisp. Served with our tomato basil dipping sauce (nut).

    $7.00
  • Sweet Potato Fries (Basket)

    Thin cut sweet potatoes piled high with honey cinnamon dipping sauce.

    $12.00
  • Sweet Potato Fries (Side)

    Thin cut sweet potatoes piled high with honey cinnamon dipping sauce.

    $7.00

Wings & Fingers

includes side or bleu cheese and celery. You choose your sauce - Hot,Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki
  • Single Wings (10)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $20.00
  • Double Wings (20)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $33.00
  • Triple Wings (30)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $49.00
  • Bucket Wings (50)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $65.00
  • Chicken Fingers (4)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $15.00
  • Chicken Fingers (7)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $22.00
  • Chicken Fingers (10)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $29.00
  • Chicken Fingers (20)

    You choose your sauce - Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, House Spicy Cajun

    $50.00

Entrees

Add small house salad to any Entree for only $3
  • Chicken Marsala

    Tender chicken medallions sautéed with fresh mushrooms in a rich and slightly sweet Marsala wine sauce, served alongside a generous portion of Mama Rose’s Restaurant Spaghetti. A comforting Italian favorite, made with love and tradition in every bite.

    $30.00
  • Chicken Parmesan

    Lightly breaded chicken breast topped with Mama Rose's Restaurant tomato sauce, melted mozzarella served over a bed of Mama Rose's Restaurant Spaghetti.

    $27.00
  • Chicken Cacciatore

    Grilled Chicken medallions in a marinara sauce with peppers, onions, and splash of Sherry served over a bed of Spaghetti.

    $28.00
  • Sausage Cacciatore

    Fresh sausage links in a marinara sauce with peppers, onions, and splash of Sherry served over a bed of Spaghetti.

    $28.00
  • Eggplant Parmesan

    Lightly breaded eggplant topped with marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella served over a bed of Spaghetti.

    $26.00
  • House Salad (Small)

    Mixed greens, ripe tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, garbanzo beans, and carrots tossed with your choice of dressing.

    $9.00
  • Caesar Salad (Small)

    Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, crunchy homemade croutons, and freshly grated cheese.

    $10.00

Pasta

  • 10-Layer Lasagna Bolognese

    Imported pasta layered with rich, slow-simmered Bolognese sauce, creamy béchamel, and a blend of Italian cheeses, baked to perfection and finished with fresh Romano. Served with garlic bread stick.

    $30.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Cheese Ravioli

    Twelve cheese ravioli topped with Mama Rose's Restaurant homemade tomato sauce.

    $22.00
  • Chicken Piccata

    Sautéed chicken, capers, and artichoke hearts in a lemon white wine sauce served over angel hair pasta.

    $30.00
  • Gemelli Pasta

    Twist pasta tossed with oil and garlic, roasted red peppers, broccoli, kalamata olives, and topped with crumbled feta cheese.

    $24.00
  • Lobster Ravioli

    Ten lobster ravioli topped with our homemade tomato basil sauce.

    $28.00
  • Mac & Cheese

    The way you remember it as a kid! American and Cheddar/Jack cheeses tossed with Gemelli pasta.

    $20.00
  • Mama Rose's Restaurant Spaghetti

    Spaghetti tossed in Mama Rose's Restaurant homemade tomato sauce.

    $16.00
  • Mama Rose's Restaurant Spaghetti (Side)

    A Buffalo Tradition Since 1952. A beloved recipe passed down through the generations, our homemade tomato sauce is slow-simmered with ripe tomatoes, herbs, and a touch of love. Tossed with tender spaghetti and finished with a dusting of Romano Cheese, this dish is severed with a garlic bread stick.

    $12.00
  • Pasta Maria

    Cheese tortellini in a light garlic cream sauce with Portobello mushrooms, and Romano cheese.

    $27.00
  • Shrimp Scampi

    Sauteed shrimp with garlic, tomatoes, white wine, herbs, and lemon butter sauce tossed with spaghetti.

    $32.00
  • Spaghetti Parmesan

    Spaghetti tossed in Mama Rose's Restaurant homemade tomato sauce then topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

    $19.00
  • Tomato Cream Penne

    Penne style pasta with sausage, mushrooms, and onions in a tomato cream sauce.

    $28.00
  • Tossed Penne

    $16.00
  • Traditional Bolognese

    Slow-simmered, homemade Bolognese sauce crafted with a rich blend of tomatoes, savory beef, pork, and aromatic herbs, lovingly tossed with ribbons of fresh tagliatelle pasta. Finished with a sprinkle of Parmesan and a touch of fresh basil. A comforting taste of Italy, straight from our kitchen to your plate.

    $28.00
  • Zesty Chicken Pasta

    Grilled blackened chicken breast, sauteed broccoli and Portobello mushrooms in a Cajun cream sauce tossed with Gemelli pasta.

    $28.00
  • House Salad (Small)

    Mixed greens, ripe tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, garbanzo beans, and carrots tossed with your choice of dressing.

    $9.00
  • Caesar Salad (Small)

    Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, crunchy homemade croutons, and freshly grated cheese.

    $10.00
  • Gluten Free Tossed Penne

    Gluten-free penne pasta tossed with our homemade gluten-free marinara sauce.

    $18.00
  • Gluten Free Chicken Cacciatore

    Grilled Chicken medallions in a gluten-free marinara sauce with peppers, onions, and a splash of sherry wine served over gluten-free penne pasta.

    $28.00
  • Gluten Free Sausage Cacciatore

    Fresh sausage links in a gluten-free marinara sauce with peppers, onions, and a splash of sherry wine served over gluten-free penne pasta.

    $28.00
  • Gluten-Free Mediterranean Pasta

    Roasted red peppers, broccoli, kalamata olives, garlic, and oil tossed with gluten-free penne pasta.

    $24.00

Calzones

All calzones include a side of tomato sauce or bleu cheese.
  • Build Your Own Calzone

    Build your own calzone. Start with either our red or white sauce, mozzarella cheese, and add any two ingredients from the pizza and calzone toppings. Extra toppings charged at calzone topping price on pizza page 10

    $12.00
  • Chicken Calzone

    Grilled chicken, spinach, roasted red peppers, ricotta, mozzarella, and feta cheese.

    $21.00
  • Chicken Finger Calzone

    Chicken fingers, bleu cheese, tomatoes, onions, hot sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

    $22.00
  • Chicken Parmesan Calzone

    Breaded chicken, mushrooms, onions, our tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

    $20.00
  • Hawaiian Calzone

    Pineapple, ham, our tomato sauce, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese.

    $18.00
  • Meat Lovers Calzone

    Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, our tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

    $21.00
  • Meatball Calzone

    Mama Rose's meatballs, our tomato sauce, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese.

    $20.00
  • Philly Steak Calzone

    Steak, mushrooms, onions, our tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

    $21.00
  • Portobello Calzone

    Spinach, roasted portobello mushrooms, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, and fontina cheese.

    $21.00
  • Sausage Calzone

    Sausage, sweet peppers, onions, our tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

    $18.00
  • Vegetable Calzone

    Roasted vegetables, pesto, our tomato sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, and Asiago cheese.

    $20.00

Pinsa

Pinsa is a traditional Roman-style flatbread that has gained popularity as an alternative to pizza. Its name is derived from the Latin word pinsere, which means "to stretch or press." Pinsa has a unique texture and flavor profile due to its distinctive dough, which is made from a blend of different flours such as wheat, rice, and soy. This combination, along with a higher water content and longer fermentation time, results in a lighter, crispier crust that is easier to digest compared to traditional pizza dough. Though rooted in ancient Roman recipes, pinsa has seen a resurgence in popularity, especially in Italy and increasingly around the world, thanks to its health-conscious appeal and versatility.
  • Pinsa - Build Your Own

    Our Roman-style flatbread starts with light, airy dough for a deliciously crisp bite. Choose your base: classic Red Tomato Sauce or savory White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Add your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), and we’ll finish it with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $17.00
  • Pinsa Antonio

    A Roman-style flatbread with a crispy yet airy crust, topped with savory White Oil & Herb sauce, tender sliced steak, sweet caramelized onions, and vibrant sweet peppers. Finished with creamy, melted Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this flavorful combination delivers the perfect balance of rich, savory, and sweet in every bite.

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Bella Rosa

    A crispy, airy flatbread inspired by Roman tradition, topped with a flavorful White Oil & Herb sauce, tender grilled chicken, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sweet peppers. Melted to perfection with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Caprese

    A traditional Roman-style flatbread with a light, airy crust, topped with our rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, vibrant fresh basil pesto, and ripe diced tomatoes. Finished with creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $20.00
  • Pinsa Carissa

    A Roman-style flatbread with a light, airy crust, topped with our savory White Oil & Herb Sauce. We pile on grilled chicken, fiery jalapeños, and sweet peppers, then turn up the heat with our medium tomato salsa. A rich, melty blend of Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella ties it all together. Served with a side of cool, creamy sour cream for the perfect balance.

    $27.00
  • Pinsa Cheese Steak

    A Roman-style flatbread masterpiece! Our Steak & Cheese Pinsa starts with a light and airy pinsa crust, baked to perfection and topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce. We layer it with thinly sliced steak, sautéed hot banana peppers, and crispy fried onions, then smother it in our creamy cheesesteak sauce. Finally, we load it up with a mouthwatering blend of fontina, cheddar-jack, Romano, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella cheeses.

    $27.00
  • Pinsa Chicken Finger

    Experience the perfect fusion of Roman tradition and Buffalo flavor! Our Buffalo Chicken Pinsa starts with a light, crispy Roman-style flatbread, topped with a rich white oil & herb sauce. Layered with crispy, golden chicken fingers, chunky bleu cheese, fresh diced tomatoes, and onions, it's then finished with a drizzle of bold hot sauce and a decadent blend of asiago and Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A must-try for any Buffalo chicken lover!

    $27.00
  • Pinsa Cruciano

    A Roman-style flatbread with a crispy, airy crust, topped with our signature tomato pizza sauce, golden-brown breaded chicken fingers, sautéed mushrooms and onions, and a rich blend of Romano cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Felice

    A crispy-yet-airy traditional Roman flatbread, topped with a rich white oil & herb sauce, delicate slices of prosciutto, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sautéed spinach. Melted to perfection with creamy fontina and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this handcrafted dish delivers a savory, indulgent bite in every slice. A true taste of Italy!

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Hawaiian

    Experience the perfect balance of sweet and savory with our Hawaiian Pinsa—a Roman-style flatbread that’s light, crispy, and irresistibly delicious. Topped with our signature tomato pizza sauce, diced Sahlen’s ham, juicy pineapple, and a mouthwatering blend of Monterey Jack, sharp Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $23.00
  • Pinsa Lucca

    A crisp yet airy traditional Roman-style flatbread topped with our rich, slow-simmered homemade tomato pizza sauce, hand-rolled homemade meatballs, sautéed hot banana peppers for a bold kick, creamy ricotta, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Nicholas

    A traditional Roman flatbread, light and crispy, topped with our rich, house-made tomato pizza sauce, savory Italian sausage, and tender broccoli. A touch of crushed red pepper adds the perfect kick, while Pecorino Romano and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella create a perfectly melted, flavorful finish.

    $24.00
  • Pinsa Nina

    A crisp yet airy traditional Roman flatbread, crafted with our rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Topped with fire-roasted red peppers, bold and tangy gorgonzola cheese, and luscious, creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $21.00
  • Pinsa Rebecca

    A traditional Roman-style flatbread with a light, airy crust, topped with our signature White Oil & Herb sauce. Layered with sweet, roasted red peppers, savory caramelized onions, and a premium blend of Asiago cheese and Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this dish delivers the perfect balance of rich, bold flavors in every bite. A must-try for flatbread lovers!

    $23.00
  • Pinsa Sergio

    A traditional Roman-style flatbread, light and airy with a perfectly crisp crust. Topped with a savory white oil & herb sauce, fire-roasted red peppers, tender artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, and creamy feta cheese. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella

    $26.00
  • Pinsa Sicilian

    A traditional Roman-style flatbread with a light, airy crust, topped with our rich white oil & herb pizza sauce. Layered with thinly sliced tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic, then finished with a perfect blend of sharp Pecorino Romano and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $19.00
  • Pinsa Viaggio

    A traditional Roman-style flatbread with a crispy yet airy crust, topped with our rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a medley of seasonal roasted vegetables, and dollops of creamy ricotta cheese. Drizzled with our house-made fresh basil pesto and finished with a generous layer of premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture. A rustic, flavorful take on an Italian classic!

    $23.00

Kids Meals

Choice of soft drink in spill proof cup.
  • Kid's Fingers and Fries

    Two Chicken Fingers with side of fries and beverage in a take home kids cup.

    $9.00
  • Kid's Macaroni & Cheese

    American and Cheddar/Jack cheeses tossed with Gemelli pasta with a beverage in a take home kids cup.

    $9.00
  • Kid's Spaghetti with Butter

    Kid's Spaghetti tossed in butter with a beverage in a take home kids cup.

    $9.00
  • Kid's Spaghetti with Mama Rose's Restaurant Sauce

    Kid's Spaghetti tossed in Mama Rose’s Restaurant homemade tomato sauce with a beverage in a take home kids cup.

    $9.00
  • Kid's Teeny Tomato Pie

    Choice of cheese or cheese and pepperoni personal pizzas with a beverage in a take home kids cup.

    $9.00

Desserts

  • Apple Crisp A La Mode

    Warm Apple Crisp with a side of Vanilla Ice Cream.

    $7.50
  • Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4oz)

    Huge 4oz Fresh Baked Chocolate Chunk Cookie

    $3.00
  • Chocolate Decadent Torte (Gluten Free)

    $7.50
  • Chocolate Lava Cake

    $8.50
  • Chocolate Sundae - 2 Scoops

    $5.00
  • Colossal NY Style Cheesecake

    Indulge in the grandeur of our Colossal New York-Style Cheesecake, a majestic centerpiece of creamy delight. This classic dessert starts with a thick, buttery graham cracker crust, providing a satisfying crunch that perfectly complements the dense, rich filling. Made with the finest cream cheese, fresh eggs, and a hint of vanilla, each bite melts in your mouth, offering the quintessential New York cheesecake experience. Served in generous portions, this colossal creation is a true testament to indulgence, perfect for sharing or savoring solo.

    $8.00
  • Hot Fudge Sundae - Two Scoops

    $6.00
  • Lemon Italian Cream Cake

    Two layers of delicate white sponge cake filled with a luscious Italian lemon mascarpone mousse. Finished with a golden crumb coating on the sides and a light dusting of confectioners' sugar for a touch of sweetness. Bright, creamy, and irresistibly smooth—an elegant ending to any meal.

    $8.00
  • Vanilla Ice Cream - 2 Scoops

    $4.00
  • Snickerdoodle Cookie (4oz)

    Indulge in our delectable Large Snickerdoodle Cookie – a timeless classic that never fails to delight the senses. Crafted with care and precision, our oversized Snickerdoodle Cookie boasts a perfect balance of soft, chewy texture and irresistible cinnamon-sugar flavor. Each bite unfolds with a comforting blend of buttery richness and warm spices, reminiscent of cozy kitchens and cherished family recipes. Baked to perfection, our Snickerdoodle Cookie is generously sized to satisfy even the heartiest of cravings. Whether enjoyed with a steaming cup of coffee, a cold glass of milk, or simply savored on its own, this beloved treat promises a nostalgic journey with every bite. Indulge in a taste of tradition with our Large Snickerdoodle Cookie – a true crowd-pleaser that never goes out of style.

    $3.00
  • peanut butter cookie

    $3.00
  • Strawberry Italian Cream Cake

    Two layers of delicate white sponge cake filled with luscious Italian strawberry mascarpone mousse. Finished with a golden crumb topping on the sides and a light dusting of confectioners’ sugar for a touch of sweetness. A refreshingly creamy and elegant dessert.

    $8.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Extras

  • Chicken Breast (6oz) (Piece)

    Your choice of how you would like these chicken breast prepared. Price is per piece and each breast is 6oz.

    $6.00
  • Coleslaw (5oz side)

    5oz Coleslaw Side

    $2.50
  • Coleslaw (Quart)

    Quart Coleslaw Side

    $5.99
  • Dressing (2.5oz)

    Add extra dressing or a second dressing.

    $1.00
  • Dressing (Pint)

    $6.00
  • Dressing (Quart)

    Quart of Dressing

    $9.00
  • Extra Bleu Cheese (2.5oz)

    2.5oz Side of Bleu Cheese

    $1.25
  • Extra Ranch (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Extra Side

    Choose an extra side

    $2.50
  • Extra Wing Sauce (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Garlic Bread Stick

    One Garlic Bread Stick

    $1.00
  • Hot Sauce (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Mama Rose's Sauce (8oz)

    $3.00
  • Mama Rose's Sauce (Quart)

    $9.00
  • Marinara Sauce (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Marinara Sauce (Quart)

    $9.00
  • Mayo (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Meatball (Piece)

    One homemade beef Mama Rose's Meatball.

    $3.00
  • Pesto (2.5oz)

    Homemade Pesto

    $1.00
  • Pesto Cream Sauce (Quart)

    $9.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Pita Med Style

    Toasted Pita with Oil, Herbs, Garlic, and Romano Cheese. Cut in Triangles.

    $4.00
  • Pizza Crust ($5)

    Our homemade dough topped with olive oil, fresh herbs, and Romano cheese.

    $5.00
  • Salsa (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Side - Red Sauce (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Sour Cream (2.5oz)

    $1.00
  • Tartar Sauce (2.5oz)

    $1.00

My Tomato Pies (Pizza)

Your Tomato Pies (Build Your Own Pizza)

  • Pizza Bread

    Our homemade dough topped with olive oil, fresh herbs, and Romano cheese. Served with our basil pesto (nut) and tomato sauce for dipping.

    $13.00
  • Personal 7" Pizza

    Start with our signature homemade pizza dough and choose your base: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Customize your creation with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), then we finish it off with the finest Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $8.00
  • Small 12" Pizza

    Start with our signature homemade pizza dough and choose your base: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Customize your creation with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), then we finish it off with the finest Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $18.00
  • Large 16" Pizza

    Start with our signature homemade pizza dough and choose your base: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Customize your creation with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), then we finish it off with the finest Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Crafted just the way you like it!

    $25.00
  • Gluten Free 10" Pizza

    Start with our homemade pizza dough and choose your sauce: Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Then, customize your pizza with your favorite toppings (available at an additional cost), all finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Gluten-Free Notice: Please verify that your selected toppings are gluten-free before ordering. "Gluten-Free" designations are based on information provided by our ingredient suppliers. However, due to shared cooking and preparation areas, we cannot guarantee that any menu item is completely free from gluten or other allergens. If you have any food allergies or sensitivities, please inform a manager when ordering.

    $17.00

Personal Specialty

  • Personal Antonio Pizza

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful White Oil & Herb sauce, thinly sliced steak, sweet caramelized onions, and vibrant sweet peppers. Finished with rich, melty Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of savory and sweet. A bold, satisfying bite in every slice!

    $12.00
  • Personal Bella Rosa Pizza

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce, tender grilled chicken, savory roasted portobello mushrooms, and sweet peppers. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt.

    $12.00
  • Personal Caprese Pizza

    Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, vibrant fresh basil pesto, and ripe diced tomatoes. Finished with creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this pizza is a perfect balance of fresh, savory flavors baked to golden perfection. A true taste of Italy!

    $10.00
  • Personal Carissa Pizza

    A bold fusion of flavors on our homemade pizza dough, topped with a savory White Oil & Herb Sauce. We layer on grilled chicken, fiery jalapeños, and sweet peppers, then add a kick with our medium tomato salsa. A melty trio of cheeses—Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella—brings it all together. Served with a side of cool, creamy sour cream for the perfect balance. A spicy, cheesy masterpiece!

    $12.00
  • Personal Cheese Steak Pizza

    A bold twist on a classic favorite! Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce, then layered with thinly sliced steak, sautéed hot banana peppers, and crispy fried onions for the perfect balance of heat and savoriness. Smothered in our creamy cheesesteak sauce, this pie is loaded with a mouthwatering blend of fontina, cheddar-jack, Romano, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella cheeses—all baked to golden perfection. Savory, cheesy, and packed with flavor—this is not your average steak pizza!

    $13.00
  • Personal Chicken Finger

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful white oil & herb sauce, crispy chicken fingers, chunky bleu cheese, diced tomatoes, and onions. Finished with a drizzle of hot sauce and a perfect blend of asiago and Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a bold, cheesy kick. A Buffalo favorite with every bite!

    $12.00
  • Personal Cruciano

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with our signature tomato pizza sauce, crispy breaded chicken fingers, sautéed mushrooms and onions, a blend of Romano cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $12.00
  • Personal Felice

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich white oil & herb sauce, thinly sliced prosciutto, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sautéed spinach. Finished with creamy fontina cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfectly melty, flavorful bite.

    $12.00
  • Personal Hawaiian

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a rich layer of our signature tomato pizza sauce, diced Sahlen’s ham, sweet pineapple, and a blend of Monterey Jack, sharp Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory and sweet, baked to golden perfection.

    $11.00
  • Personal Lucca

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with rich, slow-simmered homemade tomato pizza sauce, hand-rolled homemade meatballs, sautéed hot banana peppers for a spicy kick, creamy ricotta cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $12.00
  • Personal Nicholas

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with rich, house-made tomato pizza sauce, savory Italian sausage, tender broccoli, and a kick of crushed red pepper. Finished with Pecorino Romano and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect blend of bold flavor and cheesy perfection.

    $11.00
  • Personal Nina

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Layered with fire-roasted red peppers, bold and tangy gorgonzola cheese, and creamy, melt-in-your-mouth Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory, aromatic, and indulgent flavors in every bite.

    $10.00
  • Personal Rebecca

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce. Layered with sweet roasted red peppers, savory caramelized onions, and a blend of Asiago cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfect balance of flavor.

    $11.00
  • Personal Sergio

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a savory white oil & herb sauce, fire-roasted red peppers, tender artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, and creamy feta cheese. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $12.00
  • Personal Sicilian

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce. Layered with thinly sliced tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic, then finished with a blend of sharp Pecorino Romano and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $10.00
  • Personal Viaggio

    Our signature homemade pizza dough, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a medley of seasonal roasted vegetables, creamy ricotta cheese, and our house-made fresh basil pesto. Finished with a generous layer of premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $11.00

Small Specialty

  • Small Antonio

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful White Oil & Herb sauce, thinly sliced steak, sweet caramelized onions, and vibrant sweet peppers. Finished with rich, melty Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of savory and sweet. A bold, satisfying bite in every slice!

    $27.00
  • Small Bella Rosa

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce, tender grilled chicken, savory roasted portobello mushrooms, and sweet peppers. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt.

    $27.00
  • Small Caprese

    Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, vibrant fresh basil pesto, and ripe diced tomatoes. Finished with creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this pizza is a perfect balance of fresh, savory flavors baked to golden perfection. A true taste of Italy!

    $21.00
  • Small Carissa

    A bold fusion of flavors on our homemade pizza dough, topped with a savory White Oil & Herb Sauce. We layer on grilled chicken, fiery jalapeños, and sweet peppers, then add a kick with our medium tomato salsa. A melty trio of cheeses—Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella—brings it all together. Served with a side of cool, creamy sour cream for the perfect balance. A spicy, cheesy masterpiece!

    $28.00
  • Small Cheese Steak Pizza

    A bold twist on a classic favorite! Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce, then layered with thinly sliced steak, sautéed hot banana peppers, and crispy fried onions for the perfect balance of heat and savoriness. Smothered in our creamy cheesesteak sauce, this pie is loaded with a mouthwatering blend of fontina, cheddar-jack, Romano, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella cheeses—all baked to golden perfection. Savory, cheesy, and packed with flavor—this is not your average steak pizza!

    $28.00
  • Small Chicken Finger

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful white oil & herb sauce, crispy chicken fingers, chunky bleu cheese, diced tomatoes, and onions. Finished with a drizzle of hot sauce and a perfect blend of asiago and Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a bold, cheesy kick. A Buffalo favorite with every bite!

    $28.00
  • Small Cruciano

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with our signature tomato pizza sauce, crispy breaded chicken fingers, sautéed mushrooms and onions, a blend of Romano cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $27.00
  • Small Felice

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich white oil & herb sauce, thinly sliced prosciutto, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sautéed spinach. Finished with creamy fontina cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfectly melty, flavorful bite.

    $27.00
  • Small Hawaiian

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a rich layer of our signature tomato pizza sauce, diced Sahlen’s ham, sweet pineapple, and a blend of Monterey Jack, sharp Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory and sweet, baked to golden perfection.

    $24.00
  • Small Lucca

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with rich, slow-simmered homemade tomato pizza sauce, hand-rolled homemade meatballs, sautéed hot banana peppers for a spicy kick, creamy ricotta cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $27.00
  • Small Nicholas

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with rich, house-made tomato pizza sauce, savory Italian sausage, tender broccoli, and a kick of crushed red pepper. Finished with Pecorino Romano and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect blend of bold flavor and cheesy perfection.

    $25.00
  • Small Nina

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Layered with fire-roasted red peppers, bold and tangy gorgonzola cheese, and creamy, melt-in-your-mouth Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory, aromatic, and indulgent flavors in every bite.

    $22.00
  • Small Rebecca

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce. Layered with sweet roasted red peppers, savory caramelized onions, and a blend of Asiago cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfect balance of flavor.

    $24.00
  • Small Sergio

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a savory white oil & herb sauce, fire-roasted red peppers, tender artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, and creamy feta cheese. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $27.00
  • Small Sicilian

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce. Layered with thinly sliced tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic, then finished with a blend of sharp Pecorino Romano and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $20.00
  • Small Viaggio

    Our signature homemade pizza dough, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a medley of seasonal roasted vegetables, creamy ricotta cheese, and our house-made fresh basil pesto. Finished with a generous layer of premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $24.00

Large Specialty

  • Large Antonio

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful White Oil & Herb sauce, thinly sliced steak, sweet caramelized onions, and vibrant sweet peppers. Finished with rich, melty Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of savory and sweet. A bold, satisfying bite in every slice!

    $34.00
  • Large Bella Rosa

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce, tender grilled chicken, savory roasted portobello mushrooms, and sweet peppers. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt.

    $34.00
  • Large Caprese

    Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, vibrant fresh basil pesto, and ripe diced tomatoes. Finished with creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella, this pizza is a perfect balance of fresh, savory flavors baked to golden perfection. A true taste of Italy!

    $29.00
  • Large Carissa

    A bold fusion of flavors on our homemade pizza dough, topped with a savory White Oil & Herb Sauce. We layer on grilled chicken, fiery jalapeños, and sweet peppers, then add a kick with our medium tomato salsa. A melty trio of cheeses—Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella—brings it all together. Served with a side of cool, creamy sour cream for the perfect balance. A spicy, cheesy masterpiece!

    $35.00
  • Large Cheese Steak Pizza

    A bold twist on a classic favorite! Our homemade pizza dough is topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce, then layered with thinly sliced steak, sautéed hot banana peppers, and crispy fried onions for the perfect balance of heat and savoriness. Smothered in our creamy cheesesteak sauce, this pie is loaded with a mouthwatering blend of fontina, cheddar-jack, Romano, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella cheeses—all baked to golden perfection. Savory, cheesy, and packed with flavor—this is not your average steak pizza!

    $35.00
  • Large Chicken Finger

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a flavorful white oil & herb sauce, crispy chicken fingers, chunky bleu cheese, diced tomatoes, and onions. Finished with a drizzle of hot sauce and a perfect blend of asiago and Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a bold, cheesy kick. A Buffalo favorite with every bite!

    $35.00
  • Large Cruciano

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with our signature tomato pizza sauce, crispy breaded chicken fingers, sautéed mushrooms and onions, a blend of Romano cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $34.00
  • Large Felice

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with a rich white oil & herb sauce, thinly sliced prosciutto, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sautéed spinach. Finished with creamy fontina cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfectly melty, flavorful bite.

    $34.00
  • Large Hawaiian

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a rich layer of our signature tomato pizza sauce, diced Sahlen’s ham, sweet pineapple, and a blend of Monterey Jack, sharp Cheddar, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory and sweet, baked to golden perfection.

    $31.00
  • Large Lucca

    Our signature homemade pizza dough topped with rich, slow-simmered homemade tomato pizza sauce, hand-rolled homemade meatballs, sautéed hot banana peppers for a spicy kick, creamy ricotta cheese, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $34.00
  • Large Nicholas

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with rich, house-made tomato pizza sauce, savory Italian sausage, tender broccoli, and a kick of crushed red pepper. Finished with Pecorino Romano and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect blend of bold flavor and cheesy perfection.

    $32.00
  • Large Nina

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce. Layered with fire-roasted red peppers, bold and tangy gorgonzola cheese, and creamy, melt-in-your-mouth Galbani Professionale mozzarella. A perfect balance of savory, aromatic, and indulgent flavors in every bite.

    $28.00
  • Large Rebecca

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb sauce. Layered with sweet roasted red peppers, savory caramelized onions, and a blend of Asiago cheese and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfect balance of flavor.

    $31.00
  • Large Sergio

    Our homemade pizza dough topped with a savory white oil & herb sauce, fire-roasted red peppers, tender artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, and creamy feta cheese. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $34.00
  • Large Sicilian

    Our homemade pizza dough, hand-stretched and baked to perfection, topped with a rich white oil & herb pizza sauce. Layered with thinly sliced tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic, then finished with a blend of sharp Pecorino Romano and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $28.00
  • Large Viaggio

    Our signature homemade pizza dough, topped with a rich White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a medley of seasonal roasted vegetables, creamy ricotta cheese, and our house-made fresh basil pesto. Finished with a generous layer of premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $31.00

Gluten-Free Specialty

  • Gluten-Free Antonio

    A savory masterpiece on a thin, gluten-free crust, topped with our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, tender thinly sliced steak, sweet caramelized onions, and vibrant sweet peppers. Finished with rich, melty Galbani Professionale Mozzarella, every bite is a perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $27.00
  • Gluten-Free Bella Rosa

    A crispy, thin gluten-free crust topped with our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, tender grilled chicken, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sweet peppers. Finished with a generous layer of rich, melty Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavors.

    $27.00
  • Gluten-Free Caprese

    A light and flavorful take on a classic! Our thin, gluten-free crust is topped with White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a drizzle of fresh basil pesto, ripe diced tomatoes, and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella, baked to golden perfection. A fresh, aromatic delight in every bite!

    $21.00
  • Gluten-Free Carissa

    A bold fusion of flavors on a crispy thin gluten-free crust! Our White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce lays the perfect foundation for grilled chicken, spicy jalapeños, sweet peppers, and a zesty medium tomato salsa. Topped with a melty blend of Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella, every bite delivers the perfect balance of heat and savory goodness. Served with a side of cool sour cream for dipping. Spicy, savory, and irresistibly delicious!

    $28.00
  • Gluten-Free Felice

    A crisp, thin gluten-free crust topped with our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, layered with thinly sliced prosciutto, roasted portobello mushrooms, and sautéed spinach. Finished with a rich blend of creamy fontina and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for a perfectly balanced, gourmet flavor. A savory, indulgent experience in every bite.

    $27.00
  • Gluten-Free Hawaiian

    A delicious twist on a classic! Our homemade tomato pizza sauce is topped with diced Sahlen’s ham, sweet pineapple, and a blend of Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of savory and sweet. Baked to perfection on a thin, gluten-free crust, this pizza delivers big flavor in every bite!

    $24.00
  • Gluten-Free Nicholas

    A crisp, thin gluten-free crust topped with our homemade tomato pizza sauce, savory Italian sausage, tender broccoli, and a touch of crushed red pepper for a subtle kick. Finished with Pecorino Romano and premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor.

    $25.00
  • Gluten-Free Nina

    A flavorful twist on tradition, featuring our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, fire-roasted red peppers, bold Gorgonzola cheese, and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella, all atop a thin, gluten-free crust for the perfect crispy bite. A rich and savory experience in every slice!

    $22.00
  • Gluten-Free Rebecca

    A perfectly crisp, thin gluten-free crust topped with our signature White Oil & Herb sauce, sweet roasted red peppers, rich caramelized onions, and a blend of bold asiago and creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella.

    $24.00
  • Gluten-Free Sergio

    A flavorful blend of White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce topped with fire-roasted red peppers, tender artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, and creamy feta cheese. Finished with premium Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect melt. Served on a thin, crispy gluten-free crust. A light yet satisfying taste of the Mediterranean!

    $27.00
  • Gluten-Free Sicilian

    A crispy, gluten-free thin crust topped with our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, layered with thinly sliced tomatoes, sweet onions, and fragrant garlic. Finished with a blend of sharp Pecorino Romano and rich, creamy Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor. Simple, savory, and irresistibly delicious!

    $20.00
  • Gluten-Free Viaggio

    A crispy, thin gluten-free crust topped with our signature White Oil & Herb Pizza Sauce, a medley of seasonal roasted vegetables, dollops of creamy ricotta, and a drizzle of homemade fresh basil pesto. Finished with a generous layer of Galbani Professionale mozzarella for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

    $24.00

Take-Out Beverages

2L Bottle Beverages

  • Pepsi (2L)

    $4.50
  • Diet Pepsi (2L)

    $4.50
  • Brisk Iced Tea Lemon (2L)

    $4.50
  • Starry (2L)

    $4.50

Bottled/Canned Beverages

  • Aquafina Water (20oz)

    Refreshing, clean-tasting bottled water, sourced from public water supplies and rigorously purified through a multi-step process for a pure taste.

    $2.50
  • Aunt Rosie's Loganberry (12oz)

    $2.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Brisk Iced Tea Lemon (20oz)

    $3.00
  • Crush Orange (20oz)

    $3.00
  • Diet Pepsi (20oz)

    With its light, crisp taste, Diet Pepsi gives you all the refreshment you need - with zero sugar, zero calories and zero carbs. Light. Crisp. Refreshing. Diet Pepsi. Nothing refreshes like a Diet Pepsi.

    $3.00
  • Dr Pepper (20oz)

    A refreshing, carbonated soft drink with a unique blend of 23 flavors, known for its distinct taste that is neither a cola nor a root beer, often described as a sweet, slightly spicy flavor with hints of cherry, vanilla, and citrus

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Dr Pepper Zero Sugar (20oz)

    Refreshing, crisp, and bold Dr Pepper flavor with zero sugar, perfect for those looking for a sweet taste without the calories

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Mtn Dew (20oz)

    Mountain Dew exhilarates and quenches with its one of a kind, bold taste

    $3.00
  • Mug Root Beer (20oz)

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Pepsi (20oz)

    $3.00
  • Pepsi Wild Cherry (20oz)

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Pure Leaf Sweet Tea (18.5oz)

    A real brewed iced tea made with black tea leaves, sugar, and citric acid. It's sweetened with real sugar and contains no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Pure Leaf Unsweetened (18.5oz)

    Real brewed black tea, crafted from fresh tea leaves with no added sugar, providing a clean, refreshing taste with zero calories; perfect for those seeking a naturally flavorful beverage without sweetness

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Red Bull Energy Drink (8.4oz)

    The original energy drink that gives you wings, Red Bull features taurine, an amino acid, plus four essential B-group vitamins B3, B6, B12 and B5, which contribute to normal energy-yielding metabolism

    $4.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • S. Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water (250ml)

    $4.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Squirt (20oz)

    $3.00
  • Starry (20oz)

    $3.00
  • Tropicana Apple (10oz)

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK

Gatorade

  • Gatorade Fierce Blue Cherry (20oz)

    $4.00
  • Gatorade Gatorlyte Cherry Lime (20oz)

    Quickly replenishes your body with electrolytes you lose in sweat. Made with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $5.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Gatorade Gatorlyte Mixed Berry (20oz)

    Quickly replenishes your body with electrolytes you lose in sweat. Made with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $5.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Gatorade Gatorlyte Strawberry Kiwi (20oz)

    Quickly replenishes your body with electrolytes you lose in sweat. Made with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $5.00
  • Gatorade Gatorlyte Strawberry Kiwi Zero (20oz)

    Quickly replenishes your body with electrolytes you lose in sweat. Made with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $5.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Gatorade Gatorlyte Watermelon (20oz)

    Quickly replenishes your body with electrolytes you lose in sweat. Made with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.

    $5.00
  • Gatorade Lemon Lime (11.6oz)

    With a legacy over 50 years in the making, Gatorade is the most scientifically researched and game-tested way to replace electrolytes lost in sweat. Gatorade Thirst Quencher is trusted by some of the world's best athletes.

    $2.00
  • Gatorade Zero Glacier Cherry (20oz)

    With a legacy over 50 years in the making, Gatorade is the most scientifically researched and game-tested way to replace electrolytes lost in sweat. Gatorade Thirst Quencher is trusted by some of the world's best athletes.

    $4.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Gatorade Zero Grape (20oz)

    With a legacy over 50 years in the making, Gatorade is the most scientifically researched and game-tested way to replace electrolytes lost in sweat. Gatorade Thirst Quencher is trusted by some of the world's best athletes.

    $4.00
  • Gatorade Zero Lemon Lime (20oz)

    $4.00
  • Gatorade Zero Watermelon Splash (20oz)

    $4.00

Saranac (Non-Alcoholc)

  • Saranac 1888 Shirley Temple (12oz)

    The taste kids love (and let's not kid ourselves, we all love it, but as adults we just often show restraint), Saranac Shirley Temple is the maraschino cherry flavored soda that we all remember.

    $3.00
  • Saranac 1888 Sparkling Lemonade (12oz)

    Our Sparkling Lemonade is made with Meyer Lemon, which has a smoother and fruitier lemon character. This soft drink is bubbly and bright, sweet and fresh, and crisp and clean. Enjoy straight-up or as a mixer!

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Saranac 1888 Orange Cream (12oz)

    A hand-crafted soda that will take you back to the days of the old soda fountains, where mouth watering oranges and real cream were mixed to make a delicious, wonderful treat.

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Saranac 1888 Root Beer (12oz)

    Hand-crafted Saranac Root Beer is made in small batches in a hometown Brewery, with a flavor that will take you down memory lane. The classic taste features fresh vanilla and licorice notes, with the rich, creamy head that only a real brewery root beer can achieve.

    $3.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Take-Out Liquor/Beer/Wine

Must be 21 to Order and must have ID at pickup.
  • 6-Pack Allegheny IPA (Cans)

    6-Pack Allegheny IPA (Cans)

    $8.99
  • 6-Pack Coors Light (Cans)

    6-Pack Coors Light Cans

    $5.99
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 6-Pack Miller Lite (Cans)

    6-Pack Miller Lite (Cans)

    $5.99
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 6-Pack Molson Canadian (Cans)

    6-Pack Molson Canadian (Cans)

    $5.99
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Allegheny IPA Can

    12oz Can of Allegheny IPA

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Genesee Can

    12oz Can of Coors Light

    $4.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Catering - Drop Off

Sandwich and Wrap Platter Drop-Off

House Salad, Pasta Salad, Choice of sandwich or wrap, Assorted cookie tray & Assorted 2-Liters
  • Sandwich Drop-Off

    ** TURKEY FOCACCIA* Oven Roasted Turkey Breast, lettuce, tomato, melted Monterrey Jack and Cheddar Cheese on Homemade Focaccia Bread with cranberry Mayonnaise. ** TUNA MELT FOCACCIA-Tuna with lettuce, tomato, melted Monterrey Jack and Cheddar Cheese on Homemade Focaccia Bread. ** HAM FOCACCIA- Thinly sliced Ham, melted Provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, melted Monterrey Jack and Cheddar Cheese on Homemade Focaccia Bread with pesto mayonnaise.

    $16.00
  • Deluxe Sandwich Drop-Off

    ** BLACKENED CHICKEN FOCACCIA- Cajun seasoned Chicken Breast with melted monterey jack and cheddar cheeses, sliced red onion, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing on homemade focaccia bread. ** PORTOBELLO MELT FOCACCIA- Roasted Portobello Mushrooms, mixed greens, garlic mayonnaise spread with melted Fontina cheese served on homemade focaccia bread. ** TURKEY FOCACCIA* Oven Roasted Turkey Breast, lettuce, tomato, melted Monterrey Jack and Cheddar Cheese on Homemade Focaccia Bread with cranberry Mayonnaise. ** HAM FOCACCIA- Thinly sliced Ham, melted Provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, melted Monterrey Jack and Cheddar Cheese on Homemade Focaccia Bread with pesto mayonnaise.

    $17.00
  • Wrap Drop-Off

    $16.25
  • Individually Wrapped Sandwiches

    Choice of Individually Wrapped Sandwiches for Catering Drop-Off

    $17.00

Pizza Drop-Off

MUST SELECT QUANTITIES OF 4:
  • Pizza And Salad Drop-Off

    House Salad, Choice of Specialty Pizzas (Minimum 2 Large Slices per person) (Select 1 Lg Pizza for every 4 people, orders with too many pizzas selected with be cancelled or changed without notice) (Must be ordered in multiples of 4) Assorted Cookie Tray & Assorted 2-Liters

    $11.50
  • Deluxe Pizza Drop-Off

    House Salad Mediterranean Platter Choice of Specialty Pizzas (Minimum 2 Large Slices per person) (Select 1 Lg Pizza for every 4 people, orders with too many pizzas selected with be cancelled or changed without notice) (Must be ordered in multiples of 4) Assorted cookie tray Assorted 2-Liters.

    $13.50
  • Pizza, Wings, Chicken Fingers/Person

    $16.00

Italian Drop-Off

  • Simple Italian Drop-Off

    House Salad, Pizza Bread Sticks, Baked Penne Pasta, Chicken Parmesan (one Chicken Breast per person), Assorted Cookie Tray & Assorted 2-Liters.

    $16.50
  • Deluxe Italian Drop-Off

    House Salad, Pizza Bread Sticks, Garlic Roasted Red Potato, Baked Penne Pasta, Meatballs in Sauce ( one meatball per person), Chicken Parmesan (one Chicken Breast per person), Assorted Cookie Tray & Assorted 2-Liters.

    $20.00

Gourmet Salad Drop-Off

Toasted Wheat Pita, Grilled Chicken, Choice of Salad & Bottle water.
  • Gourmet Salad Drop-Off

    ** CAESAR SALAD- Crisp Romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, crunchy Homemade croutons and freshly grated cheese. ** MEDITERRANEAN SALAD- Mixed greens with tomatoes, red onions, kalamata olives and Feta cheese in a Lemon Vinaigrette. ** STRAWBERRY & GOAT CHEESE SALAD- Mixed greens with strawberries, goat cheese, candied walnuts and red onions tossed in Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing.

    $16.00

Boxed Lunch Drop-Off

6" Hoagy Sandwich, Potato Chips, Cookie, 20oz Bottled Soda.
  • Boxed Lunch

    Choice of Turkey or Ham: with lettuce, tomato and cheese. Mustard and mayonnaise on the side.

    $10.00

Desserts

  • Cookies/person

    $1.60
  • Snickers Pie

    $45.00
  • Heath Bar Tort

    $45.00
  • Key Lime Pie

    $45.00
  • Peanut Butter Pie

    $45.00
  • Ice Cream Cake

    $35.00

Individually Wrapped Packages

All Items will be Individually Wrapped
  • Individually Wrapped Burgers

    $16.00
  • Individually Wrapped Half Sandwiches

    $9.00
  • Individually Wrapped Sandwiches

    Choice of Individually Wrapped Sandwiches for Catering Drop-Off

    $17.00

Catering - My Burger Bar

10 Packs - My Burger Bar

Ten Packs include everything for 10 people to enjoy.
  • Classic 10 Pack

    10 Classic Burgers (American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, and house sauce (contains nut), 10 Sides of Fries, 10 Large Cookies, 10 Bottles Sodas

    $200.00
  • Loaded 10 Pack

    $249.00
  • Extra Person - Loaded 10 Pack

    $27.00

Desserts

  • Cookies/person

    $1.60
  • Snickers Pie

    $45.00
  • Heath Bar Tort

    $45.00
  • Key Lime Pie

    $45.00
  • Peanut Butter Pie

    $45.00
  • Ice Cream Cake

    $35.00

My Burger Bar - Catering Sides

  • 10 Pack of French Fries

    10 Sides of Fries served in one Hotel Pan.

    $19.00
  • 10 Pack of Sweet Potato Fries

    10 Sides of Sweet Potato Fries served in one Hotel Pan.

    $29.00
  • 10 Pack of Onion Rings

    10 Sides of Onion Rings served in one Hotel Pan.

    $25.00
  • 10 Pack of Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls

    10 Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls served in one Hotel Pan.

    $24.00
  • 10 Pack of House Salads

    10 Small House Salads Served in One Large Bowl with two choices of dressing.

    $30.00

Catering - It's My Birthday

Packages - It's My Birthday

  • It's My Pizza Drop-Off

    Exclusive to It’s My Birthday Buffalo! Treat your party guests to a crowd-pleasing feast from My Tomato Pie! This all-inclusive catering package features our rich and creamy homemade Mac & Cheese, piping hot hand-tossed Pizzas, freshly baked Cookies, and refreshing beverages. Perfect for kids, parents, and everyone in between — delicious, stress-free, and birthday-approved!

    $11.50
  • Mac and Fingers Drop-Off

    Exclusive to It’s My Birthday Buffalo! Treat your party guests to a delicious spread from My Tomato Pie! This kid-approved package includes our rich and creamy homemade Mac & Cheese, your choice of crispy Chicken Fingers or saucy Chicken Wings, fresh-baked Cookies, and a refreshing Beverage to complete the celebration. Perfect for birthdays with big appetites and even bigger smiles!

    $12.00

Please Select for Curb Side Pick Up:

Curb Side Pick Up

  • Please Select for Curbside Pick Up:

My Tomato Pie Location and Hours

(716) 838-0969
3055 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Amherst, NY 14228
Open now • Closes at 10PM
View menu
Facebook logoX logo (formerly Twitter)
This site is powered byToast logo
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement